Monday, January 3, 2011
Here is the first story that ran after Ed Masterson and Clifton Rushing issued me a reprimand in retaliation for my whistleblower disclosures
Both of these guys are still employed by the Federal Aviation Administration in managerial positions
.
Ed Masterson makes over $180,000 plus benefits and bonuses for violating federal law.
Clifton Rushing makes over $150,000 plus benefits and bonuses for violating federal law.
Your tax dollars pay for their salaries. FAA is allowing them both to remain in positions where they can once again jeopardize passenger safety and retaliate against whistleblowers who are trying to protect the integrity of the ATC system.
FAA needs to FIRE ED MASTERSON AND CLIFTON RUSHING FOR VIOLATING FEDERAL LAW - the Whistleblower Protection Act.
Is FAA, ATC feud jeopardizing safety?
Wednesday, February 04, 2009
The Eyewitness News Investigators
NEWARK -- Is airline passenger safety being compromised because of feuding between the FAA and the Air Traffic Controllers union?
There is new evidence that it's happening.
A controller at Newark who claims he was trying to protect pilots and passengers has been reprimanded for disobeying orders.
The Investigators' Jim Hoffer has an exclusive report.
A few months ago, the FAA redesigned the airspace at Newark as a way to decrease departure delays by allowing more planes to take off more quickly.
But an air traffic controller who has spoken out against these plans says the FAA is now trying to silence him by threatening suspension or firing.
The FAA says the redesign of airspace enhances safety and efficiency at Newark Airport, one of the nation's busiest. It says air traffic controllers helped in the redesign plans. But this controller, an outspoken union representative at Newark tower, sees big problems in the new flight patterns.
"What we're finding is the pilots do not understand what is happening when they get on the runway at Newark Airport," air traffic controller Ray Adams said.
Two months ago, Adams was on duty at Newark tower and was told by his supervisor to direct departing planes to use the new flight pattern.
Adams: "Are you familiar with departure headings, dispersal headings?" Pilot: "That's negative." Adams: "Roger, negative."
Because the new departure deviated from the standard procedure, Adams says he wanted to make sure pilots clearly understood their directions before takeoff.
Adams: "Are you familiar with the departure headings?" Pilot: "I'm not sure that we are."
The taped communication of Adams clearly shows some pilots are confused about the departure pattern, also known as headings.
READ THE REST OF THE STORY HERE:
http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/story?section=news/investigators&id=6074540
Sunday, January 2, 2011
Ed Masterson embarassing the FAA Administrator in front of the Senate Aviation Subcommittee
FAA head admits mishandling case of Newark airport whistle-blower
Published: Thursday, December 10, 2009, 8:00 PM Updated: Thursday, December 10, 2009, 10:02 PM
By Mike Frassinelli/The Star-Ledger
NEWARK -- The head of the Federal Aviation Administration admitted to U.S. senators today that his agency mishandled the case of an air traffic controller who was booted from the control tower after raising concerns about dangerous runways at Newark Liberty International Airport.
It was an unusual admission for the head of a powerful federal agency, but FAA Administrator Randy Babbitt went even further. He said the FAA has set up an office where whistle-blowers can raise concerns without the fear of being fired.

Patti Sapone/The Star-Ledger
A Dec. 4 photo of Ray Adams, who spoke out against runway concerns at Newark Liberty International Airport.
For Newark air traffic controller Ray Adams, Babbitt’s testimony before a Senate subcommittee on aviation safety amounted to a national vindication of his long solitary battle against the agency.
"When someone raises a question and they have to ‘blow a whistle’ to get the
information to us, we’ve already had a breakdown, we’ve already had a slip
in the system," Babbitt said. "If people bring us safety things, we should
be dealing with them — and I want these handled differently."
The remarks followed aggressive questioning by U.S. Sen. Frank R. Lautenberg (D-N.J.), who said he didn’t want to hear again about air traffic controllers having their jobs threatened for raising safety concerns. A story on Adams and his struggles with the FAA appeared in Sunday’s Star-Ledger.
Adams two years ago complained about the runway intersections at Newark Liberty. From the control tower, he watched near-crashes and saw pilots befuddled by changing flight operations.
The FAA removed Adams from the control tower on what he said was a trumped-up charge of "not following orders." Meanwhile the agency tried to keep landing patterns status quo at the runway intersections.
READ THE REST OF THE STORY HERE:
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2009/12/faa_head_admits_mishandling_ca.html
Saturday, January 1, 2011
Happy New Year - 2011 begins without Clifton Rushing at EWR
nananana....nananana....heyheyhey..goodbye......CLIFTON
2011 is a good year for the FAA to FIRE ED MASTERSON AND CLIFTON RUSHING FOR THEIR VIOLATIONS OF FEDERAL LAW - The Whistleblower Protection Act.
On December 22nd of 2009 a federal administrative judge ruled that ED MASTERSON VIOLATED FEDERAL LAW. In the same ruling it was determined that CLIFTON RUSHING was complicit in VIOLATING FEDERAL LAW. The Whistleblower Protection Act protects federal employees (like me) from reprisal for making protected disclosures.
I disclosed three unsafe procedures at Newark Liberty International Airport in New Jersey. Ed MASTERSON AND CLIFTON RUSHING took REPRISAL ACTIONS against me for protecting the SAFETY OF THE FLYING PUBLIC..as stated by Judge JoAnn Ruggiero on December 22, 2009.
FAA has not fired these managers even though the regulations say they must. FAA NEEDS TO FIRE ED MASTERSON and CLIFTON RUSHING.
I STILL HAVE NOT RECEIVED MY FULL BACKPAY. THESE PEOPLE ATTACKED MY FAMILY'S FINANCIAL WELL-BEING. FAA HAS NOT MADE GOOD ON THIS.
ED MASTERSON and CLIFTON RUSHING'S ACTIONS COST THE FAA $67,000 in legal fees to NATCA for my defense. FAA SHOULD GET THAT MONEY BACK FROM ED MASTERSON AND CLIFTON RUSHING. INSTEAD, ED MASTERSON GOT A PROMOTION AND IS MAKING over $179,000 per year plus benefits and bonuses. It's time to FIRE ED MASTERSON and take back the money he cost the Agency.
Let hope for a very disciplinary 2011......
Friday, December 31, 2010
Clifton Rushing's last day at Newark Tower
On February 2, 2008 Clifton Rushing verbally attacked me while I was controlling aircraft at Newark. Yes, that's right - WHILE I WAS WORKING LIVE TRAFFIC. Yes, there are people on those airplanes. Maybe even you, your friends or your family. His actions were disruptive to the operation and could have caused an accident.
What was FLM Rushing so bent about?? He didn't like the fact that the pilots were confused by a new procedure and they had the gall to ask me some questions. And the worst part of it all......I actually answered them!! Oh.my.God! I was doing my job --- too well.
So the marbles in FLM Rushing's head bounced around a bit and he chose to confront me while I was working airplanes. Do you know what was his solution to the pilots' questions and the dangerously confusing procedure? HE TOLD ME NOT TO ANSWER THE PILOTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What a dipsh*t...Are you F'n serious....DON'T ANSWER THEM???????
And this jackass is a SUPERVISOR in the Federal Aviation Administration. The agency tasked with protecting your life when flying!!!
Anyway, this idiot gives me a reprimand for answering questions of the pilots who don't know what the hell they're supposed to do when they takeoff from Newark Airport because of some F'd up procedure put together by a bunch of sycophant washed-out controller wannabes sitting in cubicles somewhere.
A year later, a federal administrative judge at the Merit Systems Protection Board rules that the reprimand was in VIOLATION OF THE - WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION ACT. The judge ruled that FLM Rushing was complicit in a reprisal action against the appellant (me). Clifton's actions constituted a Prohibited Personnel Practice.
FAA's own regulations state that anyone committing a PPP is subject to 30-day suspension to removal from service for a first offense and a second offense is simply removal. Well, this was the first of two PPP's that FLM Rushing committed in a period of 5 months and against the same appellant (me).
Yet, he is still gainfully employed by the FAA and getting paid over $150,000 a year plus benefits and bonuses. This guy, who would rather see a pilot run his plane into a building than answer his question, is collecting a nice, fat paycheck on the taxpayer's dime. If you want to cut the federal budget - start here!
It took almost 2 years to get to the point of this blog post, but after much complaining on my part to the highest levels of FAA administration, FLM Rushing was finally transferred out of Newark Tower. At least I don't have to look at his ugly face anymore. I did everything possible not to work with him in the control tower. It cost me money and leave time to stay away from him. I'm still waiting to get that back.
I'm sure the FAA transferred him with a paid move of $27,000 cash and probably gave him a promotion to go along with it. All these great perks for a guy who is a hazard to any airport he works at. If anyone finds him, please drop me a line. I need to warn the flying public about this guy.
OK FAA - IT'S TIME TO MAN UP AND FIRE THIS GUY. YOU HAVE THE AUTHORITY AND THE RULINGS. IF I WOULD HAVE DONE THIS, I'D BE WORKING AT 7-11 MAKING MINIMUM WAGE.
FIRE CLIFTON RUSHING. YOU KNOW YOU HAVE TO.
Love Ray.....................................
Thursday, December 30, 2010
November 27, 2009 CNN - Newark runway risks concern feds
(CNN) -- Federal investigators are concerned a potential danger persists because of the simultaneous use of intersecting runways at Newark Liberty International Airport, one of the nation's busiest and a gateway to the New York metro area.
The alert comes after repeated instances in which planes above the Newark airport flew too close to each other in violation of safety standards. There were four such instances last year and at least four this year, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation inspector general.
In one case, on January 16, 2008, two Continental planes -- a Boeing B-737 and an Embraer 145 -- missed each other by 600 feet, according to a DOT inspector general's report.
"That was very scary. I was there for that one personally in the control tower, and it scared the heck out of everybody up there," said Ray Adams, a Newark air traffic controller.
Potential danger arises when approaching planes need to abort their landings, which happens about every 700 flights at Newark, according to a Federal Aviation Administration analysis.
In what the FAA calls "go-arounds," the diverted plane approaching Newark has to make a sharp right turn through the flight path of planes landing and taking off from an intersecting runway, allowing little margin for error.
"There was a distinct possibility that we could have had a collision with these operations," Adams said.
READ THE REST OF THE STORY:
http://www.cnn.com/2009/TRAVEL/11/27/nj.runway.danger/index.html
Wednesday, December 29, 2010
An explanation of why FAA should remove Ed Masterson from service with the Federal Aviation Administration
On December 22, 2009 Merit Systems Protection Board Administrative Judge JoAnn M. Ruggiero ruled that Mr. Raymond Adams, an air traffic controller at Newark Airport, was illegally issued a reprimand by the Agency on February 22, 2008. The Judge determined that the discipline imposed on Mr. Adams was motivated by his disclosure of unsafe air traffic procedures at Newark Liberty Airport. This reprisal for whistle blowing activity is prohibited by 5 C.F.R. 2302(b)(8) and is considered a “Prohibited Personnel Practice”. The reprimand was ordered cancelled as of its effective date and per MSPB regulation 5 C.F.R. 7701(e)(1), the Judge’s initial decision became final on January 26, 2010 and is not subject to further appeal.
Judge Ruggiero’s reasoning of her decision clearly implicates Air Traffic Manager, Mr. Edward Masterson as the primary actor in the commission of the Prohibited Personnel Practice. In the Judge’s decision, she stated, inter alia, that Mr. Edward Masterson was aware of the appellant’s disclosures to Congress and the media stories regarding the unsafe procedures, and that he attended the February 2008 meeting in Representative Chris Smith’s office where the procedures were discussed. She also stated that Mr. Adams’ disclosures were “a thorn in Mr. Masterson’s side” and Mr. Masterson gave “advice” to Mr. Rushing, the appellant’s immediate supervisor that Mr. Adams would have to be “dealt with”.
Due to his extensive experience in FAA facility management, it is reasonable to believe that Mr. Masterson was well aware of the law and FAA regulation prohibiting reprisals against employees for protected disclosures. Mr. Masterson was previously the Assistant Air Traffic Manager at Philadelphia Air Traffic Control Tower and held regional management positions in FAA. It appears Mr. Masterson committed this illegal action willfully and even when put on notice that his actions constituted retaliation, he refused to reconsider.
5 C.F.R. 1221(f) dictates the action MSPB will take upon the initial decision becoming final. The relevant portion of the Statute reads:
(1) A final order or decision shall be rendered by the Board as soon as practicable after the commencement of any proceeding under this section.
(2) A decision to terminate an investigation under subchapter II may not be considered in any action or other proceeding under this section.
(3) If, based on evidence presented to it under this section, the Merit Systems Protection Board determines that there is reason to believe that a current employee may have committed a prohibited personnel practice, the Board shall refer the matter to the Special Counsel to investigate and take appropriate action under section1215. (Emphasis added)
Section 1215 dictates the procedures for the Special Counsel to follow to initiate a disciplinary action against an employee. Specifically Section 1215(a)(3) indicates the penalties that may be imposed. These penalties include removal, debarment from service for up to five (5) years, suspension, reprimand and assessment of a civil penalty not to exceed $1100.00.
According to its website www.osc.gov, “The U.S. Office of Special Counsel (OSC) is an independent federal investigative and prosecutorial agency. Our basic authorities come from four federal statutes: the Civil Service Reform Act, the Whistleblower Protection Act, the Hatch Act, and the Uniformed Services Employment & Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA).” It also states “OSC’s primary mission is to safeguard the merit system by protecting federal employee`s and applicants from prohibited personnel practices, especially reprisal for whistleblowing.” (Emphasis added)
Although the OSC has the primary responsibility for initiating disciplinary action against employees committing Prohibited Personnel Practices, the OSC may authorize the Agency to discipline the offending employee itself.
According to the FAA’s Human Resources Operating Instructions (effective July 1, 2008), Table of Penalties #40, the penalty for a first offense of committing a Prohibited Personnel Practice listed in the Personnel Management System (PMS), Introduction, Paragraph VII is a 30-day suspension to removal. In #41 of the same table, the penalty for retaliation against an alleged whistleblower is to be determined by the Office of Special Counsel. The act of retaliation against a whistleblower is a Prohibited Personnel Practice (5 CFR 2302(b)(8)).
Since the Agency (i.e. FAA) may be authorized to discipline the offending employee for the Prohibited Personnel Practice, it should immediately contact the OSC and initiate action to remove Mr. Edward Masterson from his service with the Agency. Mr. Masterson’s actions placed many thousands of lives in jeopardy and embarrassed the Agency on multiple occasions in the eyes of the Congress and the Public. He also removed Mr. Adams from the air traffic facility for over a year on administrative leave, costing the Agency over $150,000. Mr. Adams’ victory in front of the MSPB will also cost the Agency tens of thousands of dollars in attorney’s fees. Mr. Masterson should further have all bonuses and promotions gained since 2008 revoked and subsequently repaid to the Agency.
In addition to Mr. Masterson’s involvement, the Front Line Manager, Clifton Rushing was complicit in the commission of the Prohibited Personnel Practice. Mr. Rushing was the instigator of the conflicts leading up to the PPP and his actions disrupted the air traffic operation at Newark Airport on two separate occasions endangering the passengers and causing traumatic injury to Mr. Adams. Mr. Adams’ injury was confirmed by a medical professional and upheld by the Department of Labor, even over the objections of Mr. Masterson. Mr. Rushing’s actions cost the Agency tens of thousands of dollars and a great loss of productivity. The Agency has the authority to discipline Mr. Rushing for his actions. Mr. Rushing should be demoted from his position of Front Line Manager back to an Air Traffic Control Specialist and he should be reassigned to another facility. He should also have his pay reduced to its pre-promotion level. Mr. Rushing’s presence at Newark Tower continues to be an unwarranted source of tension for Mr. Adams.
In the FAA’s own Manager’s Guide to Discipline, under the heading “Provide Positive Leadership and Serve as a Role Model” it is stated that managers are held to a higher standard of behavior than the employees they supervise. It clearly reads, “Simply stated, with all things being equal, a manager would receive a greater “penalty” for his/her failure to comply with a workplace rule than a subordinate would.” For their unprofessional and illegal conduct, both of these managers should receive penalties on the high end of the suggested range.
Dec. 22, 2009 - MSPB rules Ed Masterson retaliated against me and committed a Prohibited Personnel Practice
Here's the catch - Ed Masterson received a promotion for his conviction. YES, that's right - for committing a VIOLATION of FEDERAL LAW - he got PROMOTED!!!
I'll say it again - the Merit Systems Protection Board determined that Ed Masterson - the Newark Air Traffic Manager - VIOLATED FEDERAL LAW. This isn't me talking here, it's Judge Joann Ruggiero of the MSPB in her ruling dated December 22, 2009. This VIOLATION of FEDERAL LAW - the Whistleblower Protection Act has not been punished by FAA. It was condoned and the violator - Ed Masterson- was given a promotion.
Come on FAA - it's time to fire this guy and make a public statement about it. You guys made tons of public statements about how bad a guy I was when you were trying to fire me for protecting the safety of the passengers at Newark Airport.
It's time to FIRE ED MASTERSON!!!